Elucidate Frank's view on lawyers to come out of childish mentality and become complete adult jurist.
>
0
Comments
 |
| Elucidate Frank's view on lawyers to come out of childish mentality and become complete adult jurist. |
Que: Elucidate Frank's view on lawyers to come out of childish mentality and become complete adult jurist.
Ans;
A] Introduction:
Hans Frank, a prominent German legal theorist and lawyer, held a distinct perspective on the role of lawyers and their transformation into "complete adult jurists." In his writings, Frank emphasized the need for lawyers to transcend a childish mentality, characterized by adherence to rigid rules and a narrow focus on technicalities, and instead embrace a broader understanding of justice and the law. This article explores Frank's views on lawyers' development, its implications for criminal law practice, and its relevance in modern legal systems. By analysing various aspects of criminal law, relevant sections, unique points, case laws, and scholarly references, we aim to provide a comprehensive examination of this topic.
B] Hans Frank's View on Lawyers and Complete Adult Jurists:
1.Childish Mentality of Lawyers: Frank criticized lawyers who mechanically applied legal rules without considering the broader context or ethical implications. He referred to this mindset as a "childish mentality" that prioritizes technicalities over substantive justice.
2.Complete Adult Jurists: According to Frank, complete adult jurists are those lawyers who transcend the limitations of the childish mentality. They possess a deeper understanding of justice, ethics, and the human impact of legal decisions. Complete adult jurists approach the law holistically and recognize its social and moral dimensions.
3.Importance of Legal History and Philosophy: Frank emphasized the significance of legal history and philosophy in shaping lawyers into complete adult jurists. Understanding the historical development of legal principles and the philosophical underpinnings of the law allows lawyers to apply the law more responsibly and judiciously.
C] Applicability in Criminal Law:
1.Justice-Centered Approach: Frank's call for complete adult jurists aligns with the justice-cantered approach in criminal law. Criminal lawyers must move beyond a strict adherence to statutes and technicalities and prioritize fairness and the protection of individual rights.
2.Ethical Considerations: Criminal law involves profound ethical considerations, especially when defending accused individuals. Complete adult jurists must grapple with moral dilemmas and ensure that their legal advocacy upholds fundamental rights and principles of justice.
3.Role in Sentencing: The concept of complete adult jurists is particularly relevant in sentencing. Lawyers representing defendants should advocate for sentences that consider rehabilitation, restorative justice, and the potential for reintegration into society.
D] Unique Points:
1.Social Context: Frank's views emphasize the importance of considering the social context in legal practice. In criminal law, this means recognizing the influence of societal factors on crime and the broader implications of legal decisions on communities.
2.Adversarial System and Ethical Advocacy: The adversarial nature of criminal proceedings demands a high standard of ethical advocacy from lawyers. Complete adult jurists must balance their duty to clients with their responsibility to uphold justice and fairness.
E] Case Laws:
1.Gideon v. Wainwright (1963): In this landmark U.S. Supreme Court case, the court held that indigent defendants have a constitutional right to legal counsel. The decision underscores the importance of competent representation and the ethical obligations of criminal defence lawyers.
2.R. v. Jordan (2016): The Supreme Court of Canada established strict timelines for criminal trials to ensure timely justice for defendants. This case highlights the need for efficiency and fairness in the criminal justice system, reflecting the ideals of complete adult jurists.
F] References:
- Hans Frank, "The Meaning of Adult Jurist" (1930).
- Roger Brownsword, "Rights, Wrongs and Responsibilities: The Limitations of a Childish Mentality" (2010).
- Larry Laudan, "The Importance of Problems in Criminal Procedure" (1991).
- Sanford H. Kadish, "Legal Ethics: The Moral Character of Lawyers" (1992).
G] Conclusion:
Hans Frank's call for lawyers to transition from a childish mentality to become complete adult jurists resonates with the fundamental principles of justice and ethics in the legal profession, particularly in criminal law. The concept of complete adult jurists challenges lawyers to move beyond technicalities and rigid adherence to rules and consider the broader implications of their legal decisions. In criminal law practice, this involves adopting a justice-cantered approach, acknowledging ethical considerations, and understanding the social context in which crimes occur. Through a deeper understanding of legal history and philosophy, lawyers can enhance their legal advocacy and contribute to a more just and equitable criminal justice system. By aspiring to be complete adult jurists, lawyers can fulfil their ethical responsibilities and contribute to the advancement of a fair and compassionate legal system that upholds the principles of justice and protects individual rights.
Thank you for reading!
Thank you for reading!
Tags :
Legal Theory
Post a Comment